4x11 Everything in its Right Place
First Aired: Jan. 17, 2007 on The CW
Summary: Lucas, having recovered from his heart attack, returns to school with high-hopes of restarting his new relationship with Peyton. Haley learns that Nathan involvement with Daunte caused the accident, leading Haley to be very angry at him. Meanwhile, Brooke and Rachel team up to steal the…
Main Characters in this Episode
Haley James Scott: I know you're sorry, I know that you don't want to hurt me. But I need to know that you're going to be honest with me.
Nathan Scott: I promise, I -
Haley James Scott: I need to know that you're going to let me in, Nathan. I mean, all the way.
Nathan Scott: I will, okay. I'll - I'll let you in if that's what it takes, I'll let you in. It's just... sometimes I'm afraid that if I do, you'll see the real me. The guy I was before you. And I'm not proud of that person, okay; the one that I used to be. But if I have to be that guy to keep you safe, then that's who I'm going to be. Look, if you want me to apologize for defending you, or for fighting back when somebody hurts you, then I can't do that - I won't do that, okay because the truth is: that's a guy I'll never be; a guy that just stands by and watches while the world hurts you. Can you understand that?
Haley James Scott: I can't...
Nathan Scott: Haley, you have to -
Haley James Scott: No, I can't keep standing on one foot. So, if there's more, I should sit down. But if you're done, then, um... just take me home 'cause I'm tired and I miss you and I love you, every version of you.
Nathan Scott: Come here... [They hug and he kisses her forehead]
Rachel Gatina: You still smell like a whore.
- Goof (factual errors): When Lucas is visiting Keith's grave, you see part of the date of death, which says 23, 2006. Several seconds later as Lucas looks down on Jimmy Edwards grave, his death date says March 1, 2006. Keith and Jimmy died on the same day, during the school shooting.
- Goof (continuity error): After Lucas' heart attack Lucas visits Keith's grave and then visits Jimmy Edwards grave. Jimmy Edwards gravestone shows that they died on March 1, 2006. Not only does that mean that all of season 4 happened in 3 months but when they made the 4 year jump to season 5 it means the show would be in 2010.
- Goof (continuity error): When Lucas is in the graveyard at Keith's and Jimmy's graves, there are two different months printed on the stones.
- Goof (plot holes): On Keith's tombstone it shows his death date as the 23rd, but does not specify a month. On Jimmy's it shows the 1st of April as his death date, but they died on the same day so it should be the same.
- The episode is named after a song by Radiohead.