4x05 I Love You But I've Chosen The Darkness - One Tree Hill Episode Guide

One Tree Hill

- Episode 04x05

Episode: 04x05
Title: I Love You But I've Chosen The Darkness
Type: Regular Episode
Production Code: 3T5755
First Aired: Oct. 25, 2006

Season 4 » Episode #05 - I Love You But I've Chosen The Darkness

One Tree Hill - 04x05 I Love You But I've Chosen The Darkness

Summary: Derek's real intentions are exposed and when Lucas tries to save her from him, Derek becomes violent and attacks Peyton. As rumors continue to fly about Brooke being pregnant, Brooke sets everyone straight as to who is really pregnant. Meanwhile, Nathan receives a scholarship offer from Duke, but also receives life-changing news that forces him to rethink his scholarship offer. Elsewhere, Deb tries to break her prescription drug habit in order to go to Nathan's press conference sober.

Watch Episode Videos

Clip: Two Surprises (1:33)

Clip: The Jacket (1:49)

Clip: Derek The Stalker (3:04)

Who appeared in this episode?

Derek	played by Matt Barr
Nick Chavez	played by Rey Valentin
Nurse	played by Ashleigh Falls
Cheerleader	played by Julie Krystina
Prostitute	played by Cari Moskow
Officer	played by Michael Burgess
Detective Wilcox	played by Brett Rice
Principal Turner	played by Shawn Shepard
Derek Sommers	played by Ernest Waddell

Episode Quotes

04x05 - I Love You But I've Chosen The Darkness

Season 4 / Episode 5: - I Love You But I've Chosen The Darkness

Peyton Sawyer: [Sprays mace in Derek's eyes]
Derek: [starts running after Peyton] Ohhh... That wasn't very nice Peyton!

Season 4 / Episode 5: - I Love You But I've Chosen The Darkness

Peyton Sawyer: Can you believe this? Derek. Is it any wonder that I have commitment issues?
Lucas Scott: Yeah. You're pretty much the Bermuda Triangle of relationships.
Peyton Sawyer: Thanks.

Peyton Sawyer: Crap. Turn around.
Lucas Scott: What?
Peyton Sawyer: Turn around; I have to change.
Lucas Scott: Oh.

Peyton Sawyer: [while changing] You know, I just can't believe what a creep he turned out to be. And I just let him waltz into my house. Like "Hey, I'm a crazy psycho, can I come in?", and I'm all like "Yeah, sure! Wanna see my bedroom?"
Lucas Scott: Peyton.
Peyton Sawyer: And he's still out there.
Lucas Scott: They'll find him, ok? The detectives said they'll call when they do and then we'll finally have some answers. Until then, you're safe with me, I promise!
Peyton Sawyer: You're always saving me.

Peyton Sawyer: Ok, you can turn around.
Lucas Scott: [Turns around and sees Peyton in her cheerleader's uniform] Woah! Is this your way of saying thank you?
Peyton Sawyer: Nice try! A few of the cheerleaders have to be at Nathan's press conference.
Lucas Scott: Oh wow! I forgot about that. Wouldn't you be safer just to avoid the whole thing?
Peyton Sawyer: No, I'm not gonna hide out because of Derek. No way.
Lucas Scott: Actually I meant because Brooke might be there.

[More Quotes]