1x19 How Can You Be Sure? - One Tree Hill Episode Guide

One Tree Hill

- Episode 01x19

Episode: 01x19
Title: How Can You Be Sure?
Type: Regular Episode
Production Code: 177518
First Aired: Apr. 20, 2004

Season 1 » Episode #19 - How Can You Be Sure?

One Tree Hill - 01x19 How Can You Be Sure?

Summary: Lucas steps into Dan's shoes when he learns that Brooke might be pregnant. Not wanting to follow in his own father's footsteps, Lucas promises to be there for Brooke no matter her decision, but Brooke is reluctant to trust Lucas. Meanwhile, Haley considers having sex with Nathan.

Watch Episode Videos

Clip: Lucas Confronts Nathan (2:22)

Who appeared in this episode?

Haley James	played by Bethany Joy Galeotti
Nicki	played by Emmanuelle Vaugier
Tim Smith	played by Brett Claywell
Player #2	played by Zachary Hermann
Player #1	played by Kwame Heyward
Buyer	played by J.R. Rodriguez

Episode Quotes

Season 1 / Episode 19: - How Can You Be Sure?

Lucas: There's something I have to tell you. You should sit.
Karen Roe: Okay. I think I'll stand.
Lucas: This is gonna hurt you, Mom. And I'm sorry.
Karen Roe: What happened?
Lucas: Brooke's pregnant.
Karen Roe: [she slaps him] Oh, my God, Lucas. I'm so sorry.
Lucas: I guess I deserved that. Stupid...

Season 1 / Episode 19: - How Can You Be Sure?

Brooke: I lied.
Lucas: What?
Brooke: I'm not pregnant.
Lucas: Wha - But I saw the test.
Brooke: I know. And when the doctor called, he said I wasn't pregnant. He said that can happen.
Lucas: Okay, no-no-no-no no. I-I-I was standing right there when he called.
Brooke: And you had just called me a slut.
Lucas: So you lied to me to punish me? How could you do that?
Brooke: How could you cheat on me with my best friend?
Lucas: Brooke, I never meant to hurt you.
Brooke: That doesn't really matter, Lucas. 'Cause in the end it all hurts just the same.

[More Quotes]